Fence Repair or Replace: How To Decide
Most fences can be saved for far less than a new one. Here's how to tell whether yours is one of them.
Every week someone asks us to quote a full replacement when what they actually needed was four palings and one post. The opposite happens too — people spend good money patching a fence that was always going to fall over.
The deciding factor is almost always the posts. Palings are cosmetic and cheap to swap. Posts carry the load, and once they go, the fence goes with them.
A few palings are loose or broken
Paling replacement is straightforward and usually handled in a single visit.
One or two posts are leaning or rotted
Individual posts can be replaced and reset in concrete without touching the rest of the fence.
Storm damage to one section
If the posts either side are sound, a section can be rebuilt to match.
Posts are rotting at the base all along the fence
Once the posts fail consistently, patching becomes endless. The fence is near end of life.
The fence is leaning as a whole, not just one post
Whole-run lean usually means footing failure or ground movement under many posts.
Timber is soft, crumbly or full of termite damage
Structural timber that crumbles can't be fixed by replacing palings over the top.
The fence is 20+ years old
Not automatically, but at that age the cost of repairs accumulates quickly.
What repairs typically cost
Repairs are quoted on what's actually wrong rather than per metre, so there's no flat rate we can publish honestly. What we can say is that single-post replacements, paling swaps and section rebuilds are a fraction of the cost of a new fence — and if the rest of the run is sound, that's the answer.
A new fence starts at $145 per metre for plain timber, so a 20-metre run is roughly $2,900. That's the number to weigh a repair against.
The question worth asking yourself
If the fence is otherwise solid and one part has failed, repair it. If you're looking at the third patch in five years, or the posts are soft, the money is better spent on a new run — and a new fence comes with a clean warranty rather than a piecemeal one.
Either way, it's worth someone looking at it properly before you decide. A photo on your phone is often enough for a rough answer, and an on-site look is free.
Not sure which yours needs?
Send us a photo or we'll come out and take a look — we'll tell you honestly whether it's a repair job or a replacement.
